Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Isa remarked that had the decision on the Faizabad sit-in case been implemented, the May 9 incident might have been averted.
He expressed his perplexity regarding the report’s preparation process, criticizing the lack of clarity on responsibilities and the reliance on limited testimonies.
The Attorney General’s statement regarding ISI’s role in financial matters drew scrutiny from the Chief Justice, questioning the accountability for such issues.
He highlighted inconsistencies in the report’s findings and criticized its apparent bias against the Punjab government. The Chief Justice lamented the lack of concrete findings and accountability in the report, emphasizing the need to learn from past events. He expressed disappointment in the commission’s approach and questioned its efficacy in addressing the situation impartially.
The Attorney General’s revelation about the withdrawal of review petitions prompted skepticism from the Chief Justice regarding the commission’s credibility. He questioned the absence of TLP members’ statements and criticized the commission’s failure to call relevant witnesses.
The Chief Justice underscored the distinction between peaceful protesters and those carrying weapons, implying the latter’s disruptive intent. He also defended the act of providing food to protesters as not inherently criminal.
