In response to a letter from six judges of the Islamabad High Court, the Chief Justice of Pakistan has taken a firm stance, asserting that any executive interference in judicial matters will not be tolerated, and the judiciary’s independence will remain uncompromised.
The Supreme Court of Pakistan issued a statement indicating that the Chief Justice, Justice Qazi Faiz Isa, met with the concerned judges to address their concerns. Following the receipt of the letter in March 2024, the Chief Justice convened a meeting with the judges individually to discuss their reservations.
A subsequent meeting, lasting two and a half hours, was held at the Chief Justice’s residence, attended by judges from the Islamabad High Court. Additionally, the Chief Justice met with the Attorney General, Minister of Law and Justice, Senior Judge, and a delegation from the Supreme Court Bar Association to further address the matter.
Emphasizing the importance of judicial independence, the Chief Justice reiterated his stance against executive interference during these discussions. Subsequently, a unanimous decision was made by all Supreme Court judges to meet with the Prime Minister. Following this meeting, it was agreed to establish a high-level inquiry commission. During discussions with the Prime Minister, assurances were given regarding the preservation of judicial independence, with a commitment to legislative actions in accordance with legal precedents.
The Chief Justice underscored the non-negotiable nature of judicial independence during talks with the Prime Minister, highlighting its significance in upholding the rule of law and democracy. It was proposed that an inquiry commission be formed to investigate the concerns raised in the letter, with the Prime Minister assuring cabinet approval for its establishment. Furthermore, the Prime Minister pledged additional measures to safeguard judicial independence, including directives to relevant departments and necessary legislative initiatives.
A full-court meeting, chaired by the Chief Justice, was convened, with participation from all Supreme Court judges and Islamabad High Court judges, to discuss the letter and subsequent constitutional implications.
